Morning Commentary
President Obama was a whirlwind last week, espousing the Buffett Rule and dodging comments from Hilary Rosen. There were several aspects of the stump speech that should have raised red flags, and I mentioned several in commentaries, but the line "Social Darwinism" to describe Paul Ryan's budget and the mentality of Republicans is most telling. Essentially President Obama is saying it shouldn't come down to the survival of the fittest as to how one gets the spoils. Instead the spoils should be divided among the collective. But this idea, which has been around since the mid 1800s, has always had inherent flaws.
First is the common sense aspect of this idea that "we" are building the safety net for all when in fact too many Americas are mostly taking from that so-called safety net with little and often zero contributions. That wouldn't be so awful if the takers weren't painted so heroically while those that pump in more than they'll ever take out are being called every dirty name under the sun. In many ways all of us are examples of the fittest, which is why we roam the earth today. The notion that the meek shouldn't inherent the earth but instead be handed it on a silver platter doesn't inspire greatness. On the contrary, we are talking about punishing and stamping out the notion extraordinary.
I realize President Obama sees this struggle in the same way Joseph Fisher saw the struggle of ordinary people when he used the term "Social Darwinism" for the first time in print when he authored "The History of Landholding in Ireland" in 1877. But it is beyond the pale nuts to compare the current system of capitalism in America to the plight of the Irish in 1877. Yet, there is no doubt that the message we are going to hear suggests the rich are not doing their fair share while commercials from the administration implore more and more people to get on food stamps. I would love to see them keep it real.
> Let's hear commercials saying if you stop smoking weed you could get a job.
> Let's hear commercials about using the Internet for learning not the latest Kanye video.
> Let's hear commercials about not dropping out of school because more than likely you will be a serious drag on society.
> Let's hear commercials about God and America being great, not about how weak the nation is unless our government spends even more money.
It's time to shake up those that have quit on society. It's time to push people to do more and to be accountable. If this is all about a social contract then it's time to have one that seeks demands from all rather than a certificate of servitude in which winners spilt the prize with the quitters. If we are preaching a social contract what are the obligations for those with no skin in the game?
Bellum Omnium Contra Omnes
This idea of a social contract goes back to Thomas Hobbes, the English philosopher and author of "Leviathan."
His idea of a social contract saw as its central tenet the heavy hand and unaccountable rein of government. Just as liberals have taken the meltdown of the financial system as an opening that capitalism cannot police itself so, too, did Hobbes believe government must supersede individual and businesses rights. This was hammered home last week when President Obama said we tried capitalism in the eight years before he took office and it didn't work. (I'm not sure what he thinks we practiced in the four years of his presidency, although it hasn't been pure free markets or risk-taking as the calculation resulted in a lose-lose situation.)
When I hear " ... so everyone can take risk" I take it as a direct shot at businesses and entrepreneurs, and that somehow risking it all is a luxury and somehow if the government scoops in more money it can be the sugar daddy for everyone to have risk-free adventures including dropping out of the workforce. Even if you are in the camp of higher taxes, there has to be concern that as Hobbes believed that without an omnipotent government there would be "war of all against all" as citizens wouldn't cede to common sense, religious beliefs and simply doing the right thing as they ripped each other apart.
For Hobbes and Obama the population was beneath the sovereign authority, which could even abuse its power in return for protecting the same people that it's taken rights from.
Birds do it and Bees do it
"All things for all men, since all men have need of them, since all men worked to produce them in the measure of their strength, and since it is not possible to evaluate everyone's part in the production of the world's wealth." —Peter Kropotkin
I would never take communism or socialism seriously as an economic policy, but I have a lot more respect for the ideas from Peter Kropotkin, zoologist, philosopher, economists, writer, and revolutionary whose ideas challenged Vladimir Lenin. He felt mankind could take its cue from the animal kingdom where it wasn't about the fittest but instead the collective. He advocated for communism but without a central government. His book "Mutual Aid-a law of Nature and chief factor of progressive evolution" Kropotkin gave example after example of nature fending off predators using teamwork, including this passage about activities in the lakes of Russian and Siberian Steppes:
And here are the robbers -- the strongest, the most cunning ones, those "ideally organized for robbery." And you hear their hungry, angry, dismal cries as for hours in succession they watch the opportunity of snatching from this mass of living beings one single unprotected individual. But as soon as they approach, their presence is signaled by dozens of voluntary sentries, and hundreds of gulls and terns set to chase the robber. Maddened by hunger, the robber soon abandons his usual precautions: he suddenly dashes into the living mass; but, attacked from all sides, he again is compelled to retreat. From sheer despair he falls upon the wild ducks; but the intelligent, social birds rapidly gather in a flock and fly away if the robber is an erne; they plunge into the lake if it is a falcon; or they raise a cloud of water-dust and bewilder the assailant if it is a kite. And while life continues to swarm on the lake, the robber flies away with cries of anger, and looks out for carrion, or for a young bird or a field-mouse not yet used to obey in time the warnings of its comrades. In the face of an exuberant life, the ideally-armed robber must be satisfied with the off-fall of that life.
I suppose businesses, the profit-motivation, patents, and ownership are the robbers in the human world, but it's the exact opposite. Clean food makes its way to the masses as a result of the profit motive. Wonderful architecture and cozy homes are the reward for those willing to work hard for ownership. Excessive materialism can be nauseating, but a Picasso in your living room would be a nice exclamation point for a life of hard work. A Patek Philippe to leave your son or daughter is grand. A small plot of land to call your own is joyous. The point is our system is the best, and field mice have the tools to beat the robbers.
I do find it interesting the left never talks about Kropotkin because in the end it's about power for them and indentured servitude for the masses. There is something innate about competition among animals and mankind. For human beings competition and reward help push the boundaries and have yielded remarkable things that make life more enjoyable. Artificially suppressing these urges creates a downward spiral that mask a deterioration of economic safety and the importance of pushing the boundaries. It's been tried and failed miserably in several parts of the planet including modern day European nations.
Pain in Spain
Bond yields on Spanish and Italian debt spiked this morning and are sending sirens throughout the trans-Atlantic financial community. The action in the bond market underscores the legitimacy of worries that these two nations could be time bombs. By the same token we could see the ECB (Europe's version of the Federal Reserve) swing into action with more free money via LTRO3. (The LTRO program is long term repurchase operations that see dirt cheap cash pumped into European banks in hopes it saves them and even sees some trickle onto Main Street. It hasn't been the success many say it has or we wouldn't be talking about doing it for a third time. The threat is one day it doesn't trickle out of the banks but comes gushing out and drowns those countries with so much money that inflation is inevitable).
Key ten year yields.
> Germany 1.73
> Spain 6.14
> Italy 5.63
I find it amazing that Spain did everything President Obama says would spark the US economy and few talk about the flawed game plan that now has that nation with 26% official unemployment and more than 50% for its young adults. Considering how much work, sweat, and panic were exhausted in saving Greece (for now) I can't see how could the "powers that be" allow this situation to falter further. Of course the real cure has less to do with bailouts and more to do with recouping that notion of competition, greed, pride and achievement.
The official red flag would be a move above 7.0% for the ten year yield. I say everyone should already be seeing red.
Today's Session
Equity futures have edged higher on economic data including Retail Sales and earnings results. There are mixed messages from the Empire State report which saw a nice increase in employment and even prices received, but general business came in well below consensus.
Comments |
None of the above: it's just an inequitable tax system. A flat-tax setup will cure most of our "ills." And yes, I vote. George Stelzenmuller on 4/16/2012 10:23:18 AM |
Do away with it and have a national sales tax. That would be fair for everyone who spends a dollar in this country. Bill Bloodworth on 4/16/2012 10:27:15 AM |
If everyone paid what I paid we wouldn't have a deficit. I want to see a list of names for the people I'm supporting so I can contact them & find out what they did today. tom stender on 4/16/2012 10:28:31 AM |
Taxes are too high Denny T. on 4/16/2012 10:32:18 AM |
If elections were held the first Tuesday after April 15, the outcome might be very different. Tim Tougas on 4/16/2012 10:50:39 AM |
Obama and all that are waiting for their "fair share" to be given to them would do well by reading: "As a Man Thinketh" by James Allen. It is a quick read and I would love to see what insights you glean from that book as well Charles. KVOSS on 4/16/2012 11:08:55 AM |
I don't particularly feel that my tax rate is unfair, but I have no confidence that it will be well spent. The more money the government gets, the more will be spent. Marianne Hamilton on 4/16/2012 11:37:53 AM |
If the federal government had its way, "SPQR" would be our motto too. Socialism is the government doing by force what Godly people do as charity. Just as you identified the robbers on the Siberian Steppes, it is quite clear who the robbers are here on our own steps - it is a government out of control and out of touch with the Constitution and the ideals of the founding fathers. Madison and Jay must be turning over in their graves to see their ideals devolve into what they tried so hard to escape. The government by, of and for the people has become a class of Robber Barons, a den of thieves and we-the-people have become their serfs. We slept as the thieves slowly stripped us of our rights. We did not object when they instituted a direct tax on individuals in absolute violation of Article 1, Section 9, Clause 4 of the Constitution. We were silent when they abolished the gold standard in favor of fiat money. We slumbered when they abdicated their responsibility for printing money and gave that responsibility to the federal reserve. We used to be called the silent majority but now we are called the awakening giant. Let us pray to God that government comes to its senses before we-the-people become an angry mob. George on 4/16/2012 11:39:08 AM |
First of all the current tax code is the result of Congress/lobbyists incorporating their favors into the system. I believe we should have a flat tax system with 1---everyone above poverty paying somethine 5% ? and three levels above 10 to 100k-15 to 500k-20 above corporate 20 Cap gains 20 Deductions: Charity yes, Mortgage yes up to $750k 1 home, Depreciation & Equipment yes Death tax no Congress cannot meet with any law or accounting lobbyists until after law is passed with a limit of 100 pages. J.Lee John Lee on 4/16/2012 11:45:02 AM |
You think that any of these "movie star leftists and guys like Buffett" who say taxes are too low, would write a check to the Treasury for say, another 20% of their earnings? Terry O'Connor on 4/16/2012 11:56:20 AM |
We do need to pay something, but I think tax rates are too high and the tax code is too complicated. Tax rates could be lowered if everyone would pay their “fair share”. I am especially irked by those who pay no income tax and have the right to vote, even with no ID, and also the hedge fund people who pay capital gains rates on their billions in income. Of course, they trump the votes of millions of voters by putting large amounts of their money in the pockets of our their politicians in Washington. I have never voted for a tax hike of any kind: bond issues, sales tax, property tax, etc. and never will. The government already gets plenty of our money, they just need to spend it the right way. Joe Daileda on 4/16/2012 12:16:39 PM |
I think the whole structure is unfair and far too many are taking more out than putting in .....individuals who could be contributing something to our society. I own a business that deals with the public and I see able bodied people daily who are thrilled to be receiving some sort of governmental assistance. faye on 4/16/2012 12:42:32 PM |
How about let's hear commercials about providing free universal preschool to all 3-4 year olds in poverty zip codes so they don't struggle and then drop out of school...how about that? You will not find printed text materials in most poverty homes...thus no reading aloud to children nor much conversation or conveying of world knowledge and vocabulary to kids in poverty homes. Additionally poverty homes are full of lots and lots of STRESS. THINK ABOUT IT. Larry Loganbill on 4/16/2012 1:33:28 PM |
The tax rate is too high, but part of the problem is there is no consideration for either coast...if I were living in Mid-America, with a lower cost of living, it wouldn't be as big an issue...although still high. Of cours we have the California state taxes also. Richard Lange on 4/16/2012 2:00:38 PM |
Charles, The rate can only be viewed within prism of 1) is the government spending money within the confines of the intended constitutional limited role (Focused); 2) of the money they do receive, do they treat the taxes with respect and care (Fiduciary); and 3) are we advancing the goals of our national declaration of liberty (Visionary)? If these three goals are not being met, any rate is too high. It is the same concept for business and for personal prosperity - government is not a special case. Take care, Saverio Saverio on 4/16/2012 2:11:01 PM |
Too high, low or just right, who knows but the Federal Gov shouldn't spend more than it takes in on taxes. Rich on 4/16/2012 2:11:55 PM |
This is my country. I love it. I'm responsible for it, just like all Americans. Whenever I drive through a beautiful section of I-5, I'm fine with the taxes I pay. When I spend the afternoon in the park, watch the Blue Angels, hear stories from immigrants thankful to live here, I'm happy I've paid my taxes. This year I'm ashamed that I've had anything to do with the ghastly mess our government has made of our country, and I wish I could get my money back. Patricia Flynn on 4/16/2012 2:56:20 PM |
Just finished watching The Iron Lady and what a great person she is for standing strong. Our income tax isn't even legal, a direst tax on the people has to be spread throghtout the citizens equally, this is a progressive tax that only works for the rich, that make the laws to protect their wealth. Remember The Battle of Athens??? Watch clip or read about it. Sam Sage on 4/16/2012 3:28:26 PM |
Tweet |
9/6/2024 1:27 PM | Topsy-Turvy Market |
9/6/2024 9:49 AM | ALL HELL TO BREAK LOOSE |
9/5/2024 1:34 PM | Lacking Conviction |
9/5/2024 10:07 AM | LOOKING FOR MOXIE |
9/4/2024 1:34 PM | Cooling Down |
9/4/2024 9:38 AM | CLOBBERED! |
9/3/2024 12:55 PM | Hissy Fit |
9/3/2024 9:37 AM | WILL THE RALLY KEEP ROLLING? |
8/30/2024 1:25 PM | End of Summer |
8/30/2024 9:44 AM | FEELING THE WARMTH |
8/29/2024 1:27 PM | Rallying even as NVDA fades |
8/29/2024 9:45 AM | NOT MEDIOCRE BUT EXPECTATIONS WERE SKY HIGH |
8/28/2024 1:54 PM | Nvidia Day |
8/28/2024 9:50 AM | DEFYING GRAVITY |
8/27/2024 1:34 PM | Nerves Ahead of NVDAs Results |
8/27/2024 9:47 AM | TENSION MOUNTS AHEAD OF NVIDIA EARNINGS |
8/26/2024 1:25 PM | Rotation to Software |
8/26/2024 9:45 AM | POWELL SEES THE LIGHT |
8/23/2024 1:10 PM | Official Start |
8/23/2024 9:36 AM | NERVES AHEAD OF POWELL’S SPEECH |
8/22/2024 1:33 PM | Bad News is Bad News |
8/22/2024 9:56 AM | TAKE THIS JOB AND SHOVE IT! |
8/21/2024 1:04 PM | Bottom Fishing |
8/21/2024 9:48 AM | PAUSE ON THE ROAD TO NEW HIGHS |
8/20/2024 1:01 PM | Juxtaposition |
More commentary archives |
Home |
Products & Services |
Education |
In The Media |
Help |
About Us |
Disclaimer | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | All Rights Reserved.
|